Showing posts with label Vote. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Vote. Show all posts

Friday, January 28, 2011

Rebuttal: Should teenagers be allowed to vote? YES!

 Well Amber, first of all, pigs can fly. Don't believe me? well, check this out.
Second of all, i disagree with you even though you had some good points. 
I think that you are making too much of a generalization. You are saying as if all teenagers, those in between the ages of 13 and 20, act the same way or think the same way. Like i said on my post, not all teenagers think the same way. Some think in a great way and some just, well, they are just immature. 
I do agree that voting is a very important decision, but do you really think that teenagers could make a huge difference in elections? They are probably not even half of the population of the people who can vote and since they are mostly influenced by adults as you said, I think it would almost be the same if that were the case because if an adult influences a teen on one side then also another adult influences another teen on the other side (confusing, I know). If influence is a factor, then it wouldn’t really matter because it would be the same amount of adults plus the number of teenagers they influenced which would be an almost evenly number per person or per side (also confusing, a little, I know).
 Our brains might not be developed to understand things like mature adults do, but it is developed enough to understand what is good and what is bad and to be able to choose which decision in an election would be the best. 
You say teens aren’t trusted with any major life decisions until they are adults, but they actually are. Don’t you think that going to a school like ASTI is a major life decision? It might not necessarily be one, but for the most part it is. That isn’t such a good example, but you cant assume that teens aren’t trusted with major life decisions because you cant prove that. Wouldn’t driving be a major life decision? When you drive you are risking a lot, I’m sure that the risk of killing someone could be a life decision. They are trusted to drive, but not to vote? Yup.

Sunday, January 23, 2011

Should teenagers be allowed to vote?

Teenagers do not all act the same way or think the same way as each other. Some are mature and some have no idea what they are doing and do not care about the consequences.Sometimes there are teenagers that have the capacity to behave like a mature adult. I have personally met people my age who seem to have that adult mentality where everything is serious. I think that most teenagers have the capacity to act mature enough to vote. I think adults make generalizations about us. They see one of us doing something immature, and they think we are all like that, but that is also a generalization; not all adults think that about us. I think that teenagers should be allowed to vote.

Teenagers are a big part of the population in this country. I think that if teenagers could vote, the results of politics would be a little different. It is true that young teenagers are probably not ready for voting, which is something really important in society. Teenagers start to become more mature as they get older. My point is that the voting age should be lowered to sixteen. Even fifteen would be okay. 

For example, in ASTI, we start to see freshmen and sophomores think critically in their work about things that matter in the world such as family, college (higher education), environment, politics, etc. We put our own opinion, and a lot of times people (adults) are impressed by us. We are like young adults. Teenagers work, since we can start working at that age. As said in this article, some of us hold part-time jobs,
some drive, and pay taxes, and seventeen year old teens even serve in the army. The why can't those who work and pay taxes vote?

At schools, there are school governments with the same idea of a normal government, except that they are run by students. If teenagers can vote for something like that, then why wouldn't they be able to vote in real elections? Teenagers that are sixteen or older (maybe fifteen) should be able to vote. There should be some kind of requirements for teenagers, maybe a test or something that can prove that they are ready to vote. That would be a fair thing to do. 


After all, isn't a democracy "a government of the people, by the people, for the people", and aren't we people?